Coronavirus Technology Solutions

April 27, 2020

 

April 23rd  Hospital Masks and Air Filtration Webinar

More Midwest Meat Processors have Coronavirus Outbreaks

Tyson Foods Plant in Washington Closed

A Range of Mask Filter Media and Designs Should be Evaluated

Global Protective Gear has Created an Innovative Fabric and Gown to Help Solve the Current Isolation Gown Shortage

Chinese Meltblown Capacity Far Exceeds That of Europe

CMPC will Manufacture Surgical Masks in Chile, Brazil, Peru and Mexico

Procter & Gamble is Converting Manufacturing Capacity to Produce Face Masks at  a Dozen Manufacturing Sites Globally

Zuiko Mask Production Line Can Produce 600 Per Minute

Wisconsin Converters Producing Masks, Wipes and Gowns

Biax-Fiberfilm Corporation has Expanded Meltblown Fabric Production for N95 Masks

Johns Manville Plant in Richland, Mississippi, Started Production of Face Mask Media

Shaoyang Textile Machinery Co Starts Up Sinopec Melt Blown Line on March 29

Reifenhauser Teams with Vietnamese Producer to Make Masks

Meltblown Capacity Insights

WHO Says Viruses May be Aerolized After Deposit on Floors

 ______________________________________________________________________________

 

April 23rd  Hospital Masks and Air Filtration Webinar

This webinar hosted by Waterloo Filtration Institute included presentations by five people. Tom Justice explained that Hospital HVAC systems are often inadequate and room air purifiers are being employed in Chinese hospitals even in non-critical areas.

Bob Burkhead explained that an N95 mask is tested on 0.1 micron particles and not 0.3 microns.  So its efficiency in removing viruses is higher than indicated by the rating.

Peter Tsai reported tests which show that electrostatically charged masks retain efficiency when cleaned with H2O2 or modest heat. 

Bob McIlvaine reviewed the large variance in market projections based on variables which are as yet unclear. Masks and filters rather than social distancing are the safest route for return to semi normal life.

Stephen Nicholas reported on efficiency requirements for health care facilities which include MERV 14 or HEPA designs for many areas.

Gajanan Bhat addressed the subject of face mask media including new membrane developments

 

https://a4ab8fba-ca84-491c-aeb8-6ed7eb13ca9f.filesusr.com/ugd/f92d3a_c9f1bb92e781456caae19d15f35e0746.pdf

More Midwest Meat Processors have Coronavirus Outbreaks

Advocates and workers from a Missouri meat processing plant are suing Smithfield Foods, asking the company to follow CDC guidelines and take steps to protect its employees from the new coronavirus.

The lawsuit, filed Thursday in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri, alleges that the company has failed to make it possible for employees at its Milan, Missouri, meat processing plant to socially distance and is enforcing policies that encourage employees to come to work sick. Smithfield Foods Executive Vice President of Corporate Affairs and Compliance Keith Lombardo said the claims in the suit are “without factual or legal merit” and include claims that had been investigated and deemed unfounded.

In Buchanan County, Missouri, a Triumph Foods pork plant in St. Joseph is the only cluster of virus outbreaks, said Mary Robertson, spokeswoman for the city of St. Joseph, which operates the local health department.

So far, 14 confirmed cases have been found among workers at the plant.

Tyson Foods Plant in Washington Closed

Tyson Foods is closing down production at its huge meat processing plant near Pasco until further notice so that all employees there can be tested for coronavirus, the company announced Thursday.

The facility, which produces enough beef in one day to feed 4 million people, employs 1,400 workers. But the plant has been struggling in recent days with worker absenteeism, scores of COVID-19 cases and community concerns about infections there, said Steve Stouffer, group president of Tyson Fresh Meats.

Company officials did not say how many employees have been infected with COVID-19 so far, but the Walla Walla County Department of Community Health reports that more than 90 Tyson employees have tested positive for the disease so far.

A Range of Mask Filter Media and Designs Should be Evaluated

Paul Gardner, former chief of the Army's Edgewood Chemical Biological Center (ECBC)  Respiratory Protection Branch was asked by McIlvaine to use his experience in evaluating new filter media for the Army and comment on recent coronavirus needs.

Paul:  A brief background:  The 2013 market survey referenced in your video was conducted in support of our research efforts to develop a low-profile, low-resistance filter for the next generation of joint-service CBRNE respirator.  At that time I was working for my previous employer, formerly U.S. Army ECBC, as leader of the Respiratory Protection Branch investigating among other efforts novel particulate filtration media.  We evaluated the media using criteria based on performance goals aimed primarily at improving the breathing resistance and reducing the overall profile of CBRNE filters used in military respirators (i.e., air-purifying gas masks). 

 Details and the rationale for the criteria can be found in the market survey report. The survey included melt-blown electrets, nanofiber, and membrane type media.  The melt-blown electrets we tested offered significantly lower resistance than non-charged nanofiber and membrane media.  Where the nanofiber and membrane (PTFE-based) media performed better was in their resistance to battlefield contaminants (e.g., oil aerosols).  The PTFE-fiber based media also offered the ability to be “micro-pleated” which improved overall performance and lent itself to the design of lower profile particulate filters with the trade-off of being slightly thicker and having higher resistance compared to HEPA-quality flat-sheet electrets.

The criteria we used to down select media for our application were for the most part significantly more stringent than I believe would be necessary for the development of a reusable “N95” type filtering facepiece respirator (FFR) for coronavirus protection for the general population. I would think that the data could be reassessed based on criteria relevant to this goal to guide the selection and evaluation of candidate nanofiber media.

As I recall, most of the nanofiber media (at least the experimental surface treated ones) we evaluated when I was at ECBC were fragile and I believe would not hold up well to washing and/or multiple use.  Although I have limited knowledge with this specific type of media, I would think that nanofiber-based media exists in the market that has been designed to be more robust for other filtration applications.

There still is the issue of higher breathing resistance inherent in nanofiber-based media compared to electrets that significance would depend on the specific performance parameters used to design the facepiece (e.g., mask surface area, breathing resistance, most penetrating particle size targeted, etc.).  For example, in my opinion the NIOSH N95 initial resistance criterion, not to exceed 35mm H20, is too high for the general population which unlike the workplace would include a higher proportion of people that could not tolerate or should not be wearing N95 masks (e.g., the elderly and/or individuals with pre-existing medical conditions like COPD, etc.).  A criterion of less than 20 mm H20 would be a more appropriate design goal for these and for that matter all wearers since the primary complaint with N95s by far is their breathing resistance, especially under moderate to high workloads.  

For the non-worker population, NIOSH N95 requirements would not apply. This would enable the design of reusable filtering facepiece masks using nanofiber or electret media that might have reduced filtration efficiency (e.g., 90%) but offer significantly improved breathing resistance, comfort, and overall wear ability.  For health care and other high risk workers, NIOSH-certified N95 masks meeting 42CFR84 requirements should be their “go to” masks for optimum protection against contagious bioaerosols.  For the immediate future, this is best served by existing electret N95 FFRs in the marketplace.

There is also the matter of mask sealing capability, N95 NIOSH-certified FFR have an assigned protection factor of 10 (i.e., individual able to achieve a quantitative fit test of at least 100).  I believe this should also be a minimum design goal for FFR designed for the general population for protection against coronavirus.  In my experience, N95 FFRs that readily meet or often exceed this protection level come in multiple sizes and/or have some sort of elastomeric sealing surface such as a neoprene, foam, or other rubber peripheral face sealing component.

Bob McIlvaine: Very informative, Paul.  You point out the challenge for many people in wearing an N95 mask which is less breathable.  Since protection of the more vulnerable is a high priority why not let them wear efficient masks with valves. In other words if a major priority is protecting the vulnerable then the concern about their contributing to viral spread would be secondary to protecting them.  What is your reaction to this and how would it effect media selection? ( We will seek an answer in one of our next Alerts)

Global Protective Gear has Created an Innovative Fabric and Gown to Help Solve the Current Isolation Gown Shortage

With the surge in demand for gowns during the current coronavirus pandemic the traditional supply chain has not been able to keep up. The primary raw material used to create gowns is a non-woven fabric that is currently in short supply. 

To solve this raw material and gown shortage Global Protective Gear is now manufacturing AAMI Level 1 and Level 2 isolation gowns by using an alternative textile. Global Protective Gear has taken a lightweight 100% polyester and then applied a polyurethane coating which results in a waterproof equivalent.  And now the company is supplying 1 million isolation gowns per week to hospitals and medical facilities around the globe for use in low risk situations.     

"We were not going to let a non-woven shortage get in the way of providing a workable isolation gown in this time of extreme need," said Gregory Lilien, CEO, about their new product. 

And since the new product is based on an actual fabric, the gowns can actually be washed and reused 5-10x.  While some users will be required to dispose after each use, in some lower risk situations the gowns can be washed and reused multiple times helping minimize costs further.  The current market price for an isolation gown is a staggering $7-15 per pc.  In certain lower risk situations, the Global Protective Gear gown can be reused multiple times bringing the cost below $1 per use.  This is a step in the right direction to help ease the current choke on the medical product supply chain. 

Global Protective Gear is also currently building a new facility to begin production of AAMI Level 3 and 4 gowns for June 2020.  

www.globalprotectivegear.com

Chinese Meltblown Capacity Far Exceeds That of Europe

EDANA, says meltblown capacity in Europe is limited, while output in Asia is much larger. In China, the No. 1 producer, companies controlled by the central government are expected to reach production of over 70 tonnes of meltblown per day, or more than 25,000 tonnes per year, including new production lines of Sinopec and China National Petroleum Corp [CNPET.UL], state media Xinhua reported on March 30. That is up from a current daily supply of 42.5 tonnes. According to EDANA , production of overall non-wovens in Europe was 2.8 million tonnes in 2019 but meltblown was only a fraction of that.

CMPC will Manufacture Surgical Masks in Chile, Brazil, Peru and Mexico

CMPC is a multinational corporation almost 100 years in existence delivering sustainable solutions to its customers and consumers. The Company produces and markets wood, pulp, packaging products, household and non-household sanitary protection products, and tissue paper.

Recently the company, through Softys, acquired a total of five machines to manufacture surgical-type masks. Two of them have already landed the weekend of April 10 in Chile and Brazil and are in the process of being assembled, while the others will be installed in Peru, Mexico and also in Brazil (adding two in that country).

Thus, CMPC will achieve a production of 18 million 500 thousand masks per month in the four countries. In each country, the masks will be delivered free of charge to public health services, and only the percentage necessary for the care of company workers will be reserved. The delivery of the masks is expected to begin in Chile in early May.

Procter & Gamble is Converting Manufacturing Capacity to Produce Face Masks at  a Dozen Manufacturing Sites Globally

According to CEO David Taylor, mask production is already up and running in China and the company has teams working to install capacity in North America, Europe, and Asia Pacific, Middle East and Africa.

One site reportedly set to begin face mask production is located in Mehoopany, PA, where production should begin making masks in mid-May.

“It will increase the supply of masks for hospitals, first responders and other organizations by reducing market demand for production and industrial use, “It helps us create a safe working environment for P&G people, and long term, it will allow us to directly help many communities across the globe where there is unprecedented need for protective supplies," says P&G Charmin and Family Care communications spokesman Loren Fanroy.

The effort requires installation of new equipment or adjustments to existing equipment, as well as new supplies and training. The company will direct donations with established partners who have the capability and reach to help those affected by the COVID-19 outbreak, Long said. The masks won’t be sold and the company won’t be able to respond to individual requests for help.

The P&G Mehoopany plant is actually two plants in one. The Family Care side of the operation employs about 1,200 and is responsible for Charmin toilet tissue and Bounty paper towels and napkins. The Baby Care operation employs about 1,000 people and is responsible for Pampers and Luvs diapers. Another site reportedly shifting to face mask production is P&G's Cabuyao City in the Philippines.

P&G has also installed new lines to start production of hand sanitizer in five manufacturing sites around the world, using it to ensure our people can continue operating safely and sharing it with hospitals, health authorities and relief organizations. The company is already  expanding manufacturing capacity further in additional facilities to bring its capacity to 45,000 liters per week when fully operational, Taylor adds.

 Zuiko Mask Production Line Can Produce 600 Per Minute

Machinery manufacturer Zuiko has developed a face mask production line capable of making 600  per minute. Each mask features a three-ply, pleated design with a nose fitting element. Zuiko has also developed alternative ear hook components as a solution to shortages of key raw materials.

The mask machine uses standard technologies from diapers and sanitary napkin machines like zero-speed splicing for continuous production, precision material lamination, and soft welding of materials. The product is inspected at several points during the converting processes and any product that is out of specification is automatically rejected by the machine. Products can be stacked into multiple pieces before exiting to the packaging equipment or exiting one piece at a time depending on the customer’s needs.

 Wisconsin Converters Producing Masks, Wipes and Gowns

Wisconsin’s Converting industry, with its wide-ranging capabilities, is committed to maintaining production at full capacity to meet challenged created by the COVID-19 pandemic according to a Nonwovens Industry analysis. These typically quiet small-to-midsize companies are often under contract to large buying entities ranging from medical distribution suppliers to retail brand partners. 

Converters produce hundreds of specialty products that are used for medical protective equipment and hospital supplies  An impressive example of the integration between industries is illustrated by Little Rapids Corporation, headquartered in Green Bay. “Our Shawano Paper Mill supplies needs for specialty paper materials at our Graham Medical and Graham Beauty Divisions,” says Kirk Ryan, CEO and president. “We convert paper, films and nonwovens into patient gowns, O.R. caps, scrubs for medical, EMS and other healthcare settings. Our printing division produces packaging and other applications.” Little Rapids products are distributed nationally.

 Biax-Fiberfilm and 5K fibers in the Fox Valley represents high tech materials qualified in N95 mask components. “We are unique with our meltblown and spunbond nonwovens for medical and mask usage,” days Doug Brown, President. “Now, we are expanding capacity beyond our two machines running flat-out in Greenville.” “The company is the only one known in Wisconsin to meet fabric requirements for the N95 mask and one of the very few in the U.S.,” says Susan Stansbury, industry consultant.

Facilities have taken careful steps to protect both their workforce and their customers from the spread of COVID-19. Many processes are naturally spread out in the industry’s factories. “The industry is automated with operators using touch-screen controls separated from fellow co-workers, only two per lengthy machine, for example,” says Masood Akhtar of CleanTech Partners. “And this industry’s output continues to assure employment, as well as maintaining supply.”

Many of these converted products are in high demand and are medical necessities. In addition, Wisconsin is home to the leading manufacturers in terms of numbers of companies and variety of wet wipes for antibacterial, sanitizing and cleansing usage. Ranging from Top Brass Inc., to Rockline Industries, KleenTest and more than a dozen other manufacturers, this converter-packaging group makes national and healthcare brands. “Like a number of companies in Wisconsin, we make these premoistened wipes in canisters and ‘flat packs’ under contracts,” says Brad McKay of Top Brass Inc. in Wittenberg, WI. Other companies such as American Custom Converting in Green Bay make folded dry wipes and other cleaning and specialty items. “We are known for our ability to adapt our equipment to meet often-urgent needs,” says John Michaud of ACC.

https://www.nonwovens-industry.com/contents/view_Content-microsite/2020-04-24/biax-fiberfilm-expands-meltblown-capacity/

Biax-Fiberfilm Corporation has Expanded Meltblown Fabric Production for N95 Masks

“We are currently running around the clock on two machines and the new capacity in Neenah will be five times higher,” says Biax-Fiberfilm President Douglas Brown. “The purchase of a former Kimberly-Clark facility in Neenah allows us additional space, plus some of the common machine parts (usually long lead time pieces) that will assist with our fast scale up.​ The plant will be a mix between old and new technology developed by Biax-Fiberfilm"

The company expects its production startup at the new facility as early as June. With Brown’s patented technology and association with the world’s premier equipment supplier, Reifenhauser, the transition is expected to be a smooth one. Three 60-inch-wide production lines are planned. The nonwoven meltblown fabric and a patented spunblown system produces fabrics that few others in the world can create. Biax-Fiberfilm is currently producing these materials at its headquarters in Greenville, WI. It is enough for about 3.5 million masks per day.

These complicated nonwovens fabrics consist of synthetic fibers stretched in an airstream and flattened into rolls for mask production. Exacting standards must be met, and quality controls are part of the process. “Our materials have been used in masks, physicians’ PPE and in the filtration industry,” says Brown. “A key is the breathable, yet tight ‘knit’ result that keeps out the virus.”

Johns Manville Plant in Richland, Mississippi, Started Production of Face Mask Media

“Johns Manville is in a unique position to serve a market that is fulfilling a great need across the world,” said Mary Rhinehart, President and CEO of Johns Manville. “We are proud of our teams in Richland and throughout JM for finding new ways to support the communities and people who are on the front lines of this global crisis.”

Most nonwoven production of face masks was abandoned in the U.S. many years ago and moved to Asia. Given the shortage of face masks in the U.S. and Europe, JM’s Engineered Products business decided to build on its existing capabilities and help fill the market demand.

“Our high-performance nonwoven material is designed to provide high levels of filtration for various types of face masks,” said John Vasuta, President of JM’s Engineered Products business. JM media meets or exceeds Level 1 BFE 95% (Bacterial Filtration Efficiency) and VFE (Viral Filtration Efficiency) requirements. These results were verified by an FDA-registered national laboratory.

The JM plant in Richland employs about 50 people and produces a variety of filtration products for various air and liquid applications using polypropylene and polyester meltblown technology. Richland’s meltblown filtration media can be found in numerous industrial, automotive, consumer products and FDA-approved food and healthcare applications.

Shaoyang Textile Machinery Co Starts Up Sinopec Melt Blown Line on March 29

Sinopec Yizheng Chemical Fibre Co. (YCFC) successfully launched its first meltblown nonwoven production line on March 29 in Yizheng, Jiangsu province, which was manufactured by Shaoyang Textile Machinery Co, affiliated to Sinomach’s subsidiary China Hi-Tech Group Corp. (CHTC). Shaoyang Textile Machinery succeeded in reducing the lead time to a month and delivered the production line 13 days earlier than the date required by the State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission of the State Council (SASAC).

As the filter layer of a surgical mask, the meltblown nonwoven material is an essential raw component in mask production. Mask production lines are expanding rapidly across the country as an urgent part of pandemic prevention and control, and a large number of manufacturers are facing a shortage of raw materials. Shaoyang Textile Machinery rose to the challenge and undertook supply of YCFC’s 12 meltblown nonwoven production lines.

After the company signed the supply agreement with YCFC on Feb 25 it took a series of effective measures to push forward the work and successfully ensured the YCFC’s first meltblown nonwoven production line would start on March 29.

When all 12 meltblown nonwoven production lines are operational YCFC will have a daily output of 12 tons of N95 meltblown nonwoven or 18 tons of surgical mask materials and be able to increase production of disposable surgical masks by 18 million pieces a day.

Shaoyang Textile Machinery is a leading enterprise in developing and manufacturing melt-blown and spunbonded nonwoven equipment in China. It has developed and produced 300 pieces of such equipment, which have been exported to more than a dozen countries and regions, with great market effect in the industry. At present, the company has received 37 orders for non-woven equipment from enterprises such as China National Petroleum Corp. and China Petrochemical Corp. as well as various countries, including India and Uzbekistan.

Taiwan, which is capable of producing 91 million masks per week, instituted a ban on exports of the material. To put Taiwan's output into perspective, the United States' largest mask producer, 3M, can supply 55 million masks per month.

The changes to the Chinese and Taiwanese markets "sent ripples through the supply chain," according to Nozi Hamadi of SWM.

Around that time, SWM and other American manufacturers began taking steps to increase production capacity. SWM boosted capacity by 250%, by hiring and training new workers and converting its Middletown, Delaware plant so it could run 24 hours a day. 

Even with that increase, Hamidi said the company has had to warn new customers about long waits and referred some to competitors.

"We're trying to not turn away people, but the reality of the situation at least for us is we're sold out well into 2020, so if we take on a new customer right now, they basically have to wait," Hamidi said. "We have to say to them that it might be until the end of 2020 or into 2021 before we can actually get you going as a new customer."

Reifenhauser Teams with Vietnamese Producer to Make Masks

German machinery manufacturer Reifenhäuser Reicofil has temporarily converted two of its test plants due to the corona pandemic to produce meltblown nonwoven fabric for face masks. The lines at its nonwovens technology center in Troisdorf, Germany, otherwise exclusively used for R&D and customer trials, are turning out meltblown nonwoven fabric for up to one million face masks daily.

German-made meltblown nonwoven fabric will be shipped to Vietnam for conversion into face masks. Image courtesy of Reifenhäuser Reicofil.

Reifenhäuser could not locate any German or European producer for further processing into face masks and says the nonwoven fabric is going to a Vietnamese manufacturer for conversion to the final product. The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the dependence of Western nations on Asian countries, particularly China, for personal protective equipment (PPE). However, Reifenhäuser continues to look for opportunities to strengthen local supply during this crisis. The company is in close contact with associations, authorities and other companies.

To become more independent from China in the area of medical supply, countries are increasingly considering setting up their own production according to Reifenhäuser Reicofil, which now supports countries and other investors to implement such projects as speedily as possible by shortening the delivery time to only 3.5 months for meltblown lines to produce the crucial middle material layer for face masks.

The first contract with the new delivery time has already been concluded. The 1.6-meter-wide Reicofil Meltblown line is scheduled to start operation in August 2020. With an annual output of 550 tonnes, the plant will produce H99 filter material for up to 1.8 million face masks a day.

Bernd Kunze, CEO of Reifenhäuser Reicofil, explains the current strategy as follows: “We have considered what contribution we can make in this crisis. This is of course mainly the fast delivery of meltblown lines to build up additional capacities. We have drastically reduced our delivery times here. But we also wanted to provide support at shorter notice. Until the currently lacking capacities are built up, we are stepping in with the test plants. Not using this capacity now would be irresponsible in our view.”

Kunze adds that material for other medical protective clothing can also be produced at short notice: “We assume that protective suits and hoods will also become scarce. We are happy to offer our help here as well. One of our pilot lines can produce the corresponding material, an SMS nonwoven, at short notice. In the medium term, however, we should also expand production capacities in Germany or Europe.”

Reifenhäuser Reicofil also supplies technology for the production of other medical protection clothing, such as surgical gowns. These products are made of an SMS nonwoven structure – a combination of spunbond (S) and meltblown (M) materials. The corresponding Reicofil composite lines can be delivered within ten to eleven months.

Meltblown Capacity Insights

Berry Global Group is adding a fabric machine to its Biesheim, France factory. The machine will spin out 720 metric tons of filtration fabric per year. That is enough for 480 million masks.  Berry has converted a pilot fabric line in Virginia to making the filter layer, but its output is only enough for 150 million masks a year.

3M is making 35 million masks a month in the U.S. and has recently been given permission to import 10 million a month from their Chinese plant. Another 5 million a month will be added to the domestic supply by the end of April, then 10 million more by June.

290 million a month epidemiologists say should go into fighting a pandemic in the U.S.

WHO Says Viruses May be Aerolized After Deposit on Floors

With new evidence suggesting the virus may linger in the air, the WHO says it is assessing the ongoing research. In a study, not yet peer-reviewed, researchers found particles of the virus in the air of rooms where patients were receiving care and adjacent hallways. The particles they identified, however, were not capable of causing infection. In another study, also not yet peer-reviewed, researchers who examined air samples in two hospitals in China raised the theoretical concern that aerosols could arise from surfaces contaminated by droplets, for instance when hospital workers shed their masks and gowns, or when floors were cleaned.

This hypothesis is supported by the experience of PathO3Gen Solutions.  The installation of foot sanitizers at the hospital entrance significantly reduces  Hospital Acquired Infections.

It is also supported by the extensive analysis of cleanrooms in semiconductor and pharmaceutical facilities.  Movement in the room increases the amount of airborne particulate.

People emit particles from their noses and mouths that are so small, instead of falling right to the ground, they can float for a time through the air. When a virus is carried by these so-called aerosols, its odds of infecting people are higher because of the potential for them to be inhaled. Since February, the WHO has said this method of transmission “can be envisaged” in health-care facilities conducting procedures such as a tracheotomy on people with Covid-19. Researchers who aerosolized it intentionally found active virus can float in the air for up to three hours.

The 5 micron or smaller aerolized particles can penetrate deeply into the lungs raising the specter of more severe infection.

Another possible route of transmission arises when infected people improperly wash their hands after using the toilet, and then touch surfaces that others come in contact with. Some patients have been found to have live virus particles in their stool. The WHO has said that the fecal-to-oral route does not appear to be a significant pathway for the novel coronavirus. To the extent it is a means of transmission, sanitizing bathrooms, food-preparation and serving areas could help slow the virus, in addition to regular hand-washing.


https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/airborne-or-not-the-evidence-on-virus-transmission/2020/04/03/e905ec5c-75d9-11ea-ad9b-254ec99993bc_story.html