Important Discussion Of Hot Gas Filtration Options Will Be Discussed In Hot
Topic Hour Thursday, April 2 at 10 a.m. (See Information Below)
Multibillion Dollar Hot Gas Filtration Market will be Technology Driven
The large market for hot gas filters is growing and changing. The drivers
are:
·
More stringent air emission limits on particulate
·
Desirability to integrate filtration with DeNOx and acid gas capture
·
Development of new systems to remove dust at high temperature
·
Development of systems to remove multiple pollutants
·
Opportunities to improve efficiency of processes and reduce greenhouse gases
There are a number of ways to remove dust from air. Dry precipitators
presently remove more dust than all the other technologies combined. On
the other hand, the market share for dry precipitators has dropped from 90
percent decades ago to closer to 50 percent now. In the future, the dry
precipitator share will drop even farther as power plants switch to fabric
filters.
Industry |
<450oF Filters |
850oF Filters |
Catalytic
Filters |
Dry Precipitators |
Scrubbers |
Wet Precipitators |
Coal-fired Power |
P |
P |
P |
P |
S |
S P |
Waste-to- Energy |
P |
P |
P |
P |
S P |
S P |
Cement |
P |
P |
P |
P |
|
|
Steel |
P |
P |
|
|
S P |
|
Sewage Sludge
Incineration |
|
|
|
|
P |
S |
Coal Gasification |
|
P |
|
|
P |
P |
Natural Gas Processing |
P |
|
|
|
|
|
Biomass Firing |
P |
P |
P |
P |
S P |
S P |
Glass Furnaces |
P |
P |
P |
P |
S |
|
Gas Turbine Intake |
P |
|
|
|
|
|
P = primary, S = supplementary (yellow = most used blue = most promising)
The industry has responded to these drivers with a range of new technologies. It
is, therefore, going to be a challenge for the operator to select the best
option for his specific situation. Here are some of the new choices:
·
Membranes and laminates with microfibers to achieve higher efficiency at
equivalent pressure drop.
·
Filter media to best deal with the large load increases caused by direct sorbent
injection of activated carbon or lime.
·
Filter media to cope with sulfuric acid condensate as coal-fired boilers burning
high sulfur coal are utilizing filters.
·
Compact pleated filters to fit inside the shell of a precipitator.
·
Filters to remove organics as well as dust.
·
Filters to reduce NOx as well as capture dust.
·
Filters to operate at 850oF.
·
Filters to operate at 500oF.
Here are some of the developments in specific industries:
Coal-fired power: DSI, catalytic
filters, removal of dust prior to air preheater, insertion of filter bags in
existing precipitators, membranes for higher efficiency, consideration of a
venturi scrubber/wet precipitator option instead of DSI fabric filter; SBS
injection and lowering air heater temperature to where a bag with 250oF
limits could be used.
Waste-to-Energy: Mercury and acid gas
capture along with dust, elimination of the first-stage filter with a system to
produce salable hydrochloric acid and valuable metals.
Cement: Coping with hazardous waste and
sewage sludge as well as kiln dust, separate loop for mercury removal and
capture, options to extract phosphorous from clinker kiln dust.
Steel: Capturing fugitive dust,
replacing precipitators with fabric filters, dealing with sinter plant
variables.
Sewage Sludge: Improving scrubber dust
removal and final capture in WESP.
Coal Gasification: Ceramic filter with
improved performance, venturi scrubber and production of rare earths and 30
percent hydrochloric acid.
Natural gas processing: Coalescing
filters for droplet removal, ionic liquid impregnated pellets for mercury
removal, filters to remove fines leaving carbon bed filters.
Biomass firing: Filters to deal with
sticky contaminants released by combustion.
Glass Furnaces: Use of the catalytic
filter with DSI injection using high reactivity lime.
Gas turbine intake: Filters to resist
the salts and moisture of offshore turbine locations, HEPA efficiency to reduce
turbine maintenance, membranes vs. nanofiber laminates, static vs. pulsed.
Filter selection decision guides in each industry will be discussed in a
Hot Gas Filtration Hot Topic Hour
slated for April 21, 2016.
$14 Trillion to be spent on Power Plant Equipment and Repairs
in the Next 25 Years
Electricity production will be up 100 percent by 2040. This will require an
investment of $14 trillion in new hardware and repair parts for existing
equipment and systems. Coal-fired generation will grow by 10 percent. One would,
therefore, expect that investment in coal-fired power generation would be less
than in other technologies. However, when you take into account repair and
upgrades, coal-fired power will require more in investment than any of the
alternatives.
World coal powered generation capacity is 2.2 million MW today and is slated to
rise by only 10 percent or only 200,000 MW during the next 25 years. The
investment needed to keep an old power plant running from age 50 to age 75 and
to be upgraded to the likely emission limits, will be nearly equal to the $2
million/MW cost of a new power plant over a 25 year period. This means that $4.4
trillion will need to be invested in coal-fired power. Much of that will be in
Asia where many new power plants will be built. Net capacity will drop in Europe
and the U.S. This does not mean that the two areas will not be spending money on
coal-fired power plants. The U.S. moratorium on new coal-fired power plants and
the necessity to maintain 200,000 MW of coal-fired capacity means that the U.S.
will have to spend $400 billion just to keep the old power plants running and
meet increasingly stringent environmental standards.
Power Plant Investment
2015-2040 |
|
Generator Type |
$ Trillions |
Coal-fired Power |
4.4 |
Gas Turbine Combined Cycle |
2.2 |
Nuclear |
2.0 |
Biomass |
0.6 |
Wind |
2.3 |
Solar |
2.8 |
Total |
14.3 |
Nuclear capacity is slated to increase from 392 GW in 2013 to more than 620 GW
in 2040. But its share of global power generation will rise just one percentage
point to 12 percent, because almost 200 reactors of the 434 operational at the
end of 2013 will be retired, they will need to be offset by new power plants.
Total investment will exceed $2 trillion over the next 25 years.
The gas turbine combined cycle power generation market will grow by more than
300 GW to over 2 million GW by 2040. Replacements, upgrades and retirements all
result in a net capital investment of $2.2 trillion.
Biomass capacity will be 300 GW in 2040. Wind capacity will be 1300 GW and solar
1000 GW.
By 2040 Chinese energy production will be twice that of the U.S. but per capital
consumption will still be only half that of the U.S. The gas turbine market in
China will be bolstered by the Chinese coal-to-gas program which will deliver
gasified coal to turbine generators throughout the country.
India today is home to one-sixth of the world’s population and is its
third-largest economy, but accounts for only 6 percent of global energy. Demand
for coal in power generation and industry will surge increasing the share of
coal to almost half of the energy mix and making India the largest source of
growth in global coal use. By 2040, Asia is projected to account for 80 percent
of coal consumed globally. Coal will remain the backbone of the power system in
many countries.
Many components of coal and gas turbine generating plants need to be replaced
frequently. Catalyst for a coal-fired power plant is replaced every 3-5 years
and every 10 years for a gas turbine power plant. Boiler feedwater valves will
be replaced more frequently in a gas turbine power plant due to the constant
cycling and phenomena such as Flow Accelerated Corrosion (FAC). Slurry pumps,
ball mills, fans and air pre-heaters in coal-fired power plants are in periodic
need of replacement parts. Both coal and gas turbine operators are now more
likely to use zero liquid discharge (ZLD) systems which are high maintenance
systems.
Coal-fired power plants are switching from electrostatic precipitators to fabric
filters. This results in
biannual purchases of new bags. Gas turbine plants now favor high efficiency
inlet filters which are more expensive and need more frequent replacement than
the low efficiency alternative.
The power plant generation market was reviewed in a McIlvaine Hot Topic Hour on
April 7.
McIlvaine publishes market reports with detailed forecasts of the power market.
They include:
59EI Gas Turbine and
Combined Cycle Supplier Program
N043 Fossil and Nuclear
Power Generation: World Analysis and Forecast
$70 Billion Filter Market in 2016
Filter revenues for mobile, medical, residential/commercial and industrial
applications will exceed $70 billion in 2016. No one company has more than 5
percent of the total market. These are the conclusions reached by the McIlvaine
Company by aggregating data in a number of its reports.
Filtration Revenues for 2016 in
Color Coded Size Segments |
|||||
|
Mobile |
Medical |
Residential |
Industrial |
Total Filter Sales |
Donaldson |
|
|
|||
Clarcor |
|
|
|||
Mann & Hummel |
|
|
|||
Daikin |
|
|
|||
Fram |
|
|
|
||
Cummins |
|
|
|||
Mahle |
|
|
|||
Pall |
|
|
|||
Filtration Group |
|||||
3M |
|
||||
Millipore |
|
|
|||
Parker Hannifin |
|
|
|||
Eaton |
|
|
|
||
Pentair |
|
|
|||
Culligan |
|
|
|
||
Dow |
|
|
|
||
Koch Membranes |
|
|
|
||
CECO |
|
|
Revenues are displayed in segments representing $ millions:
0 – 250,
250 – 700,
700 – 1400,
1400 and above
The largest market segment is stationary industrial liquid cartridges with a
2016 market of $17 billion. This is followed by the mobile liquid cartridge
market. Mobile air filters, hydraulic and compressed air filters, cross-flow
filtration, liquid macrofiltration, dust collection, HVAC filters, and
coalescing filters are the remaining product segments.
A small but rapidly growing market is filtration of diesel exhaust fluid (DEF).
Urea/water injected into engines freezes at relatively high temperatures, so
filters are needed to prevent frozen particles from reaching the engine.
Not a single company is in the top five in each category. Those in the
residential segment tend not to be in mobile. Most of the companies are U.S.
based.
Donaldson is a major player in mobile and industrial air filtration. Their sales
of liquid filtration products primarily for diesel engines have grown recently
at double-digit rates. The diesel liquid filter sales are presently $500
million. The company is not involved with commercial/residential filtration in a
significant way.
Clarcor sales of engine and other mobile filters are $600 million per year.
Process liquid filter sales are $350 million per year while industrial air
filter sales are $475 million. It is not a player in medical and residential
applications.
Mann & Hummel has made both industrial and mobile acquisitions but its purchase
of Wix with $900 million of revenue in the mobile sector was the largest
purchase.
Daikin sales in 2015 were ¥2 trillion. With the acquisition of Flanders filter
sales are ¥100 billion or $890 million.
Twenty-two percent of Parker Hannifin sales of $11 billion are in filtration and
engineered materials. Its strengths are mobile and industrial.
More details on the filter market are found at:
N064 Air/Gas/Water/Fluid
Treatment and Control: World Market
N021 World Fabric Filter and Element Market
N006 Liquid Filtration and
Media World Markets
N024 Cartridge Filters:
World Market
McIlvaine also provides custom research and complete programs:
Detailed Forecasting of Markets, Prospects and Projects
Flow Control and Treatment Companies will benefit from a
Digital Crystal Ball
The digital age has created the ability to make fortune telling a reality. The
real life version of a crystal ball is the wealth of information available to
predict markets, projects and identify decision makers. This information can be
used to change the way flow control and treatment products are marketed.
Long range purchasing plans can be determined by an organized analysis of
information which can be obtained directly from available documents or through
individuals who have specific insights.
Minutes of municipality meetings
documenting engineering study
authorization |
Consultant reports advising
course of action for companies
under public scrutiny |
Permit applications for
construction or upgrading |
Submittals to the World Bank and
other lending institutions |
|
Five Year Plans for China and
other countries |
Recent and pending regulations
which will impact the market |
LinkedIn, blogs and various
online groups with willing
volunteers of information |
Google and other search engines |
The local salesman can make a call on a municipal wastewater treatment plant but
would be unlikely to provide the same value gained from the directors meeting
minutes which outline the failure of the competitor’s equipment and his proposal
to fix it.
The power plant modification permit request which details the cost and
performance of various options provides the needed insights on product and
timing for a potential supplier.
One way suppliers take advantage of the availability of information is to
purchase sales leads. Typically the
company spends lots of money on these leads and not on market research.
In one sense, the leads are the market research.
In fact, published studies purport to
link the number of sales leads to the size of future markets.
This approach has a number of undesirable aspects:
1.
The large expenditure for sales leads draws funds away from critical market
research.
2.
Sales leads are not qualified. High
margins and order conversion result from picking and choosing projects.
3.
Since the sales lead is also being viewed by the competitors, there will be
pricing pressure and lower success rates.
4.
The timing of sales leads is often right if you are selling a commodity, but if
you are selling based on your product differentiation, you are too late.
5.
Many companies have distributors and representatives who are being paid to
uncover leads. Sales lead expense
is justified based on evaluating distributor performance rather than on boosting
sales.
If you are selling a commodity, product and price is the basis of success then
the sales lead route is probably still the best option. But, if you sell a
product based on lowest cost of ownership and not initial price, then you should
consider a whole new route using the digital crystal ball.
Detailed Forecasting of Markets, Prospects and Projects
is your digital crystal ball because:
1.
Forecasts can be provided for the precise product at the State and province
level.
2.
Project alerts provide the time to convince the customer to consider total cost
of ownership and to issue bid specifications accordingly.
3.
The large end users, OEMs, and AEs are identified.
Since they purchase more than 50 percent of the flow control and
treatment equipment, the focus on them is critical.
4.
The opportunity to connect with the end user through white papers and webinars
improves the margin and success potential.
5.
The ability to demonstrate lowest cost of ownership is the secret to success in
the global market.
For more information on this program contact Bob McIlvaine 847 784 0012 ext. 112
rmcilvaine@mcilvainecompany.com
Here are Some Headlines from the Utility E-Alert – April 8, 2016
UTILITY E-ALERT
#1267 –
April 8, 2016
COAL – US
COAL –
WORLD
§
Two Turbines
for Coal-fired Power Plant in Punta Catalina, Bina, Santo Domingo, Dominican
Republic
The
41F Utility E-Alert
is issued weekly and covers the coal-fired projects, regulations and other
information important to the suppliers. It is $950/yr. but is included in the
$3020
42EI Utility Tracking System
which has data on every plant and project plus networking directories and many
other features.
Bob McIlvaine
President
847 784 0012 ext. 112
rmcilvaine@mcilvainecompany.com